Red-brick home entrance with a white portico, navy door, shuttered sash window and burgundy oakleaf hydrangea beside worn stone paving.

Metzger Closes Dec. 19. The People It Trained Are Already Cooking All Over Richmond.

November 5, 2026

"Go to pretty much any restaurant in Richmond and you are bound to find a Metzger alumni somewhere in the kitchen or on the floor." Chef and owner Brittanny Anderson wrote that in the Instagram post announcing that Metzger Bar & Butchery will close its doors at 801 N. 23rd St. on Dec. 19, after 12 years in Union Hill. The Richmond Times-Dispatch reprinted the post.

Most closing notices include a line like that as a kindness. Hers can be checked against a map, and the map shows something about where Richmond eats now. Metzger's former cooks and bartenders are spread around the city, but the largest group of them is not in Church Hill. Their places are mostly in Scott's Addition and the Fan. Union Hill is losing its anchor restaurant, and many of the kitchens it trained are a 15-minute drive west.

What's left on North 23rd Street

There are two rooms here, and they keep different hours. Pink Room, Anderson's 18-seat cocktail bar next door at 803 N. 23rd St., reopened in late October for one last run, according to Axios Richmond. It closes on the same day as Metzger. Anderson told the Times-Dispatch the two businesses share one space and one lease, so they end together.

Metzger Bar & Butchery Pink Room
Address 801 N. 23rd St. 803 N. 23rd St.
Days and hours Tuesday–Sunday, 5–9 p.m., per Richmond Magazine in late October Thursday–Saturday, 5 p.m.–midnight
Seating Full dining room 18 seats, walk-in only, parties of four or fewer
Final night Dec. 19 Dec. 19

The calendar is tighter than seven weeks makes it sound. Pink Room is open three nights a week, so from mid-November its posted schedule leaves about six weekends, Thanksgiving weekend included, for an 18-seat room. If you have been meaning to take someone for schnitzel and spaetzle, December weekends will be the most crowded, so a weeknight in November is the easier choice.

Pink Room has a short history. It opened in May 2024 and was shut down two months later over a zoning issue, Axios reported. It reopened that fall, then took a hiatus over summer 2026. This run has small plates in the spirit of a classic dinner party, plus cocktails. Steve Yang, the beverage director, is himself a Metzger alumnus.

Why a restaurant with this record is closing

Metzger opened on June 25, 2014. Anderson ran it with partners Nathan Conway, Brad Hemp and Kjell Anderson. The menu was German and broader European: Austrian rieslings, Jägermeister spritzes, charcuterie, pickles and pâté, with Underberg to finish. Richmond Magazine notes that The Washington Post called it "the future of German restaurants" in 2018, and that Esquire put it on its 2021 list of 100 restaurants America can't afford to lose. Anderson was named a James Beard Award semifinalist for Best Chef Mid-Atlantic for her work there in 2017, the Times-Dispatch reported.

Praise did not keep the doors open. In her announcement, Anderson called this year "the nail in the coffin for us after years of changes and hardships post Covid." In 2025 she told the Times-Dispatch that restaurants faced changing dining habits, inflation squeezing the average diner, and higher staffing costs, and she predicted more closings ahead. "The pandemic changed everything about food," she said then.

She is not leaving the business. Richmond Magazine reports that she is focusing on Bar Buoy and Black Lodge. Bar Buoy is the Eastern Shore-style crab shack in Scott's Addition that replaced her second restaurant, Brenner Pass, in 2025. That move west is the first sign of where the Metzger family tree has been growing.

Where the alumni are cooking now

Richmond Magazine's farewell piece lists the people who came through Metzger's kitchen and dining room, and most of them now cook or pour west of downtown.

Scott's Addition, which has the largest group:

  • Pizzeria Delores, 3001 W. Clay St. Co-owner Max Sayer is a Metzger alumnus. Style Weekly reported in late September that it serves Sicilian-style pizza Thursday through Sunday, 5–10 p.m.
  • Slack Tide Fish Co., 1320 Summit Ave. It opened in June 2025 under brothers Thomas and Tucker Brown, according to Axios Richmond. Two Metzger alumni work there: oyster sommelier Tyler Yates runs the raw bar program, and Steve Yang wrote the opening cocktail list.
  • Bar Buoy, Anderson's own crab shack, a few blocks away.

The Fan and West Main Street:

  • Stanley's, 2601 Park Ave. James Kohler owns this Philly-themed hoagie shop, which also serves cheesesteaks and tomato pie. It is closed Tuesdays.
  • Helen's, 2527 W. Main St., where Metzger alumna Katrina Johnson works. It serves dinner Tuesday through Saturday, 5:30–9 p.m., brunch Saturday and Sunday, 10 a.m.–2 p.m., and the bar is open daily.

Church Hill:

  • Alewife, 3120 E. Marshall St., chef-owner Lee Gregory's seafood restaurant. Karen Negvesky, formerly of Sincero, now works there, and Katy Best, now of Lucky's at Kinsale, was a big part of its early success. Alewife's site lists dinner Monday through Saturday, 5–9:30 p.m., and Sunday brunch, 10:30 a.m.–2 p.m.

Farther out: Katy Best now runs Lucky's at 285 Kinsale Road in Kinsale, on the Northern Neck. Former executive chef Emma Taylor leads the kitchen at Albi, a Michelin-starred restaurant in Washington, D.C.

Count it up. Scott's Addition has three Metzger-connected restaurants within walking distance of each other. The Fan and West Main have two. Church Hill's main link is Alewife, on East Marshall Street. Other alumni, including baker Olivia Wilson, pasta chef Laine Myers and Bobby Daglio of the Mi Scuzi pop-up, cook under their own names around the city. Myers' Oro, a handmade-pasta and vegetable concept, chose 2000 Venable St. in Union Hill, about a block from Metzger's corner, according to Richmond Magazine.

What Church Hill gets next

The most concrete addition nearby is much smaller than Metzger. Yero Rudzinskas, owner of Baltik's Bagel, bought the pastel orange former Alamo BBQ building at 2202 Jefferson Ave. over the summer. In October he told Richmond BizSense he would open a second location there, with a November target. The 1950 building is about 500 square feet, and he chose it because it already had a hood, a walk-in and a grease trap. "The holy trinity of restaurant infrastructure," he called them.

The plan is a walk-up window with covered outdoor seating and the same menu as the Forest Hill Avenue shop. Hours will match that shop, 6:30 a.m. to 2 p.m., and Rudzinskas said earlier hours may follow for VCU Health employees nearby.

Put that next to Metzger and the change is clear. A 12-year sit-down dinner room with a James Beard history is closing, and a morning bagel window is moving in a few blocks away. Each of those businesses works on its own. Together they show why the next good night out from a Church Hill front door may involve a drive to Clay Street or Park Avenue.

A December plan that follows the family tree

If you want both the farewell and what comes after, this order works:

  1. A November weeknight at Metzger. Tuesday through Sunday, 5–9 p.m., as of the late-October schedule.
  2. A Thursday, Friday or Saturday at Pink Room. Go before Dec. 19, with no more than three friends, and plan to wait if all 18 seats are full.
  3. A Scott's Addition evening. Pizza at Pizzeria Delores, oysters at Slack Tide, and Bar Buoy, all within a few blocks.
  4. A Fan lunch or brunch. A hoagie at Stanley's on Park Avenue or brunch at Helen's on West Main.
  5. Back home in Church Hill. Dinner at Alewife on East Marshall, and a bagel run on Jefferson Avenue once the Baltik's window opens.

Anderson's announcement asked people to come in "these last few months" so the team could "end our run on a high note." The schedule above leaves enough nights to do that.

When a neighborhood landmark closes, people often start asking what the block will become and what that means for the homes around it. If you live near North 23rd Street and want a practical read on how Union Hill and Church Hill are changing, Terri Brennan Homes can walk you through recent sales on your streets, with no pressure. Request a free home valuation and we'll start with your address.

Let’s Find Your Dream Home

Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact me today.